![Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo - Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -](https://c8.alamy.com/comp/2EAA0CY/hilary-duffs-boyfriend-us-singer-joel-madden-from-the-rock-group-good-charlotte-poses-on-the-avenue-montaigne-in-paris-france-on-october-6-2005-photo-by-denis-guignebourgabacapresscom-2EAA0CY.jpg)
Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -
![Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo - Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -](https://c8.alamy.com/comp/2EAA0DW/hilary-duffs-boyfriend-us-singer-joel-madden-from-the-rock-group-good-charlotte-poses-on-the-avenue-montaigne-in-paris-france-on-october-6-2005-photo-by-denis-guignebourgabacapresscom-2EAA0DW.jpg)
Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -
![Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo - Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -](https://c8.alamy.com/comp/2EAA0CT/hilary-duffs-boyfriend-us-singer-joel-madden-from-the-rock-group-good-charlotte-poses-on-the-avenue-montaigne-in-paris-france-on-october-6-2005-photo-by-denis-guignebourgabacapresscom-2EAA0CT.jpg)
Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -
![Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo - Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -](https://c8.alamy.com/zooms/6/001976bd479b40288fd43b66f1c28298/2eaa0c8.jpg)
Hilary Duff's boyfriend, U.S. singer Joel Madden from the rock group 'Good Charlotte', poses on the avenue Montaigne in Paris, France, on October 6, 2005. Photo by Denis Guignebourg/ABACAPRESS.COM Stock Photo -
![Tatiana et Xavier Delarue assistent à l'allumage des feux de Noël sur l'avenue Montaigne à Paris, France, le 27 novembre 2014. Photo d'Alban Wyters/ABACAPRESS.COM Photo Stock - Alamy Tatiana et Xavier Delarue assistent à l'allumage des feux de Noël sur l'avenue Montaigne à Paris, France, le 27 novembre 2014. Photo d'Alban Wyters/ABACAPRESS.COM Photo Stock - Alamy](https://c8.alamy.com/compfr/2dy6rhj/tatiana-et-xavier-delarue-assistent-a-l-allumage-des-feux-de-noel-sur-l-avenue-montaigne-a-paris-france-le-27-novembre-2014-photo-d-alban-wyters-abacapress-com-2dy6rhj.jpg)